9 plus ties to final for 3 additional throws
| N | NCCAA | 65.86m | Rick Cleveland | Spring Arbor | 1986 |
| Lane | # | Athlete | Yr. | Team | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 447 | SEAN LEDUC | SR | ROBERTS WESLEYAN | 42.28m | 42.28m 2018 ECC Outdoor Track & Field Championships |
| 2 | 482 | CHRISTIAN WAS | SO | SOUTHWESTERN CHRISTIAN | 39.77m | 39.77m Southwestern College Relays |
| 3 | 365 | KYLE JACOBSON | SO | JUDSON | 44.18m | 44.18m UW-Whitewater Drake Alternative |
| 4 | 192 | CORBIN HARRIS | JR | CAMPBELLSVILLE | 44.02m | 44.02m Lindsey Wilson College Invitational |
| 5 | 440 | CALEB CARTER | FR | ROBERTS WESLEYAN | 44.58m | 44.58m 2018 ECC Outdoor Track & Field Championships |
| 6 | 304 | GREGORY NWAJEI | JR | GREENVILLE | 39.54m | 39.54m Big Blue Alumni Invitational |
| 7 | 518 | TYLER GONZALEZ | FR | WARNER | 37.74m | 37.74m 2018 The Sun Conference Championship |
| 8 | 134 | BAILEY LANG | SO | BETHEL (IND.) | 43.88m | 43.88m 2018 Indiana Little State Championships |
| 9 | 205 | TY DURNELL | FR | COLLEGE OF THE OZARKS | 39.51m | 39.51m Southwestern College Invitational |
| 10 | 191 | EDWIN FORD | SO | CAMPBELLSVILLE | 44.48m | 44.48m Lindsey Wilson College Invitational |
| Lane | # | Athlete | Yr. | Team | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 467 | JOHNNY BOGERT | SO | SOUTHERN WESLEYAN | 46.15m | 46.15m Conference Carolinas Championship |
| 2 | 257 | THOMAS HICKERSON | SO | GRACE | 50.91m | 50.91m Grace College Lancer Invitational |
| 3 | 244 | TANNER VAN BEEK | SO | FAITH BAPTIST BIBLE | 48.66m | 48.66m 2018 Dr. Tucker Open |
| 4 | 299 | DAVID MARTIN | JR | GREENVILLE | 48.36m | 48.36m Monmouth College Fighting Scots Outdoor Invitational |
| 5 | 207 | MILES MROWIEC | FR | COLLEGE OF THE OZARKS | 48.30m | 48.30m Central Methodist Invite |
| 6 | 295 | MATT HUGHES | SR | GREENVILLE | 48.19m | 48.19m SLIAC Championships |
| 7 | 136 | MATT MCCOWN | FR | BETHEL (IND.) | 46.75m | 46.75m 2018 Indiana Little State Championships |
| 8 | 197 | BRAYDEN RUSSELL | JR | CAMPBELLSVILLE | 45.79m | 45.79m Lindsey Wilson Classic |
| 9 | 543 | JARAAD SALAS | JR | YORK (NEB.) | 57.72m | 57.72m Jim Dutcher Memorial |
| 10 | 126 | PHILIP FOX | SR | BETHEL (IND.) | 45.58m | 45.58m Embry-Riddle Spike's Classic (college teams) |
| 11 | 540 | ROSS FRAME | JR | YORK (NEB.) | 46.22m | 46.22m Concordia Outdoor Invite |